Institutional Commitment

Community Engagement: Choosing Better, Not Doing More

As engagement ambitions grow, universities need more than enthusiasm. They need clear ways to choose priorities, allocate resources and sustain partnerships.

Governments, funding bodies, students, employers, and community partners expect universities to contribute not only through education and research, but also through inclusion, sustainability, lifelong learning, and responses to societal challenges (European Commission, 2022). These expectations reflect a broader shift towards the idea of the civic university - an institution that creates public value by actively engaging with its social, economic, cultural, and environmental context (Goddard et al., 2016).

This broader understanding of the university's role represents a positive development. Community engagement is no longer considered an optional activity at the margins of university life. It has become an important expression of how universities contribute to society. This perspective also aligns with ACEEU’s Engaged University Accreditation, which examines how engagement is embedded across institutional strategy, organisational capacity, activities, and impact.

Yet there is an uncomfortable reality that receives far less attention. While societal expectations continue to expand, institutional resources, governance structures, staff capacity, and decision-making processes remain finite. Universities are expected to respond to an ever-growing range of priorities without a corresponding expansion of time, funding, or organisational capacity. From the perspective of ACEEU’s Institutional Commitment Standard, this makes prioritisation especially important as commitment to engagement must be translated into institutional priorities and strategic decisions that are realistic and sustainable.

From expansion to prioritisation

Much of the discussion surrounding community engagement focuses on success stories. We celebrate innovative partnerships, inspiring projects, and new forms of collaboration between universities and society. These examples are valuable. They demonstrate what is possible and help institutions learn from one another.

For many years, the dominant question was how universities could engage more. More partnerships, more initiatives, more stakeholders, and more visible impact were generally viewed as signs of success. Today, a different question is emerging: how can universities make strategic choices when multiple engagement ambitions compete for limited resources, attention, and institutional capacity?

What receives less attention are the difficult questions that accompany this expansion. How much engagement is sustainable? Which responsibilities belong to universities and which should be shared with other actors? Which partnerships deserve long-term commitment? And most importantly: how should universities decide?

Universities frequently find themselves balancing competing priorities: inclusion and capacity, flexibility and coherence, participation and accountability, long-term ambitions and short-term funding realities.

These questions are rarely discussed, yet they shape the reality of institutional leadership. Community engagement is no longer simply a matter of goodwill or enthusiasm. It is becoming a matter of prioritisation and strategic choice.

What the ACE project discovered

As community engagement becomes more strategic, universities need ways to reflect on emerging tensions, anticipate future challenges, and make informed decisions about where to focus their efforts. A strategic foresight approach can help institutions move beyond individual success stories and consider the longer-term choices shaping university–community relationships. These insights were developed through the Erasmus+ project Alliance for Community Engagement in European Higher Education (ACE) and brought together in The European University Community Engagement Guide.

The strategic foresight process involved universities and external stakeholders from across Europe, and explored not only current engagement practices, but also the challenges likely to shape the future of university-community relationships.

The purpose of the foresight process was not simply to identify successful practices or emerging trends. It was to understand the strategic choices that arise when universities pursue multiple ambitions while responding to evolving societal expectations.

The process identified 16 Strategic Pressure Points for community engagement. They highlight areas where institutional ambitions, societal expectations, and organisational capacities intersect, creating tensions that require strategic choices. They function as foresight-based lenses that help universities recognise where pressures are accumulating and where decisions can no longer be postponed.

Across different countries, institutional settings, and community engagement activities, the same pattern repeatedly emerged. Universities were not struggling because they lacked commitment to engagement. Rather, they were facing tensions that could not be resolved simply by expanding existing activities. Institutions were being asked to expand inclusion while protecting organisational capacity, increase flexibility while maintaining educational coherence, strengthen participation while preserving accountability, and build long-term partnerships despite short-term funding cycles.

These are not simply operational problems. They are manifestations of deeper strategic tensions that require institutional choices.

These insights also resonate with ACEEU's Institutional Commitment Standard, which highlights the importance of embedding engagement within institutional priorities and decision-making processes. As community engagement becomes more central to institutional missions, the challenge is no longer whether engagement should occur, but how engagement-related priorities are translated into strategic decisions.

Navigating strategic tensions

The tendency to view community engagement primarily through the lens of activities can obscure the deeper challenges facing universities. A new engagement initiative may appear beneficial in isolation. A new partnership may create value. A new participation process may strengthen stakeholder involvement.

However, when viewed collectively, these initiatives create growing pressure on institutional systems.

The European University Community Engagement Guide proposes a structured pathway for navigating such tensions: identifying the pressure and its signals, recognising the common traps, formulating a boundary question, and translating the discussion into a governance decision.

Consider a university whose long-standing community partnerships were developed through externally funded projects. As funding ends, community partners expect the collaboration to continue, while responsibility increasingly falls on a few committed staff members whose relational work is neither formally recognised nor resourced. These are signals that pressure is building. A common trap would be to pursue another short-term grant or continue relying on individual goodwill. The boundary question is therefore not simply how to keep every partnership going, but which partnerships should become long-term institutional commitments and what the university is prepared to invest in sustaining them. This ultimately becomes a governance decision: determining which partnerships are central to the university’s mission, what resources can realistically be committed to them, and where clear boundaries need to be established.

Strategic community engagement requires recognising that not every opportunity can be pursued, not every expectation can be fulfilled, and not every demand can become a permanent institutional responsibility.

This does not imply retreating from society. On the contrary, it requires a more mature approach to engagement. One that acknowledges trade-offs, clarifies responsibilities, and considers long-term sustainability alongside immediate responsiveness.

Strategic engagement is not about limiting ambition. It is about ensuring that ambition remains credible.

Conclusion

Community engagement remains one of the most significant developments in contemporary higher education, strengthening the relationship between universities and society and reinforcing the public value they create. However, growing engagement ambitions also bring increased complexity.

The contribution of the Alliance for Community Engagement in European Higher Education (ACE) project lies not in proposing another model of community engagement, but in helping universities anticipate, discuss, and navigate the strategic tensions that shape community engagement across Europe. This also speaks directly to the logic of ACEEU accreditation, which encourages institutions to look beyond individual activities and reflect on how engagement is embedded in strategy, supported institutionally, and translated into sustainable practice. The ACE project provides a practical contribution to this broader process of institutional reflection and development.

Ultimately, the question for university leaders is no longer how to engage more. It is how to engage better.


Bibliography

European Commission (2022). A European Strategy for Universities.

https://education.ec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2022-01/communication-european-strategy-for-universities-graphic-version.pdf

Goddard, J., Hazelkorn, E., Kempton, L., & Vallance, P. (2016). The Civic University: The Policy and Leadership Challenges. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781784717728

Alliance for Community Engagement in European Higher Education (ACE). Project website: https://acecommunity.eu

Alliance for Community Engagement in European Higher Education (ACE) (2026). The European University Community Engagement Guide.

https://acecommunity.eu/the-european-university-community-engagement-guide



Keywords

Community engagement; Institutional commitment; Strategic prioritisation; Strategic foresight; Civic university

About the authors

Justyna Kopańska
Project Manager, International Cooperation Centre of Lodz University of Technology

Justyna Kopańska works at the International Cooperation Centre of Lodz University of Technology in Poland. She currently works on international higher education projects, including initiatives related to community engagement and European cooperation. She has more than 20 years of experience in quality assurance, international accreditation, institutional evaluation, and national and international university rankings. Throughout her career, she has supported higher education institutions in developing quality management systems and preparing for external reviews and accreditation processes. Her professional interests include sustainable development and community engagement, internationalisation, and strategic approaches to quality assurance in higher education. She is a member of the Erasmus+ Alliance for Community Engagement in Higher Education (ACE) project team.

Małgorzata Jarczyńska
Project Manager, International Cooperation Centre of Lodz University of Technology

Małgorzata Jarczyńska is a project manager at the International Cooperation Centre of Lodz University of Technology in Poland. She works on international educational projects addressing community engagement, sustainable development, inclusion, emotional intelligence, internationalisation and innovation in higher education. She is a member of the project team of the Erasmus+ Alliance for Community Engagement in European Higher Education (ACE), supporting the development of tools and approaches that help universities make community engagement more strategic, effective and sustainable. Her professional interests include international project development and implementation, cooperation with international partners, and integrating project results into institutional practice.

Acknowledgements

This article draws on work carried out within the Erasmus+ project Alliance for Community Engagement in European Higher Education (ACE), co-funded by the European Union.


Image References

by vetre @ envato